• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Broadway Pizzeria & Restaurant

At Broadway Pizzeria & Restaurant in Paterson, NJ, we believe in serving authentic, delicious pizza crafted with fresh ingredients. Founded on the idea of community and connection, our small but welcoming eatery offers a cozy spot for families and friends to gather. From our beloved Sicilian slices to the popular Big Mac Slice, every dish is made with care and passion. We pride ourselves on our friendly service and a menu that caters to all tastes, with options for takeout, dine-in, and outdoor seating. Join us to savor the flavors and feel the warmth of our culinary tradition!

LOCATIONS

Welcome to Broadway Pizzeria & Restaurant, a beloved gem nestled at 56 Broadway, Paterson, NJ. This bustling pizzeria is not just a place to grab a quick slice; it's a community hub where flavor and nostalgia blend seamlessly to create cherished memories. Known for its friendly staff and inviting atmosphere, Broadway Pizzeria offers an authentic pizza experience that caters to both locals and visitors alike.

As you step inside, you'll find that the space is cozy yet vibrant, with outdoor seating available for those who prefer to enjoy their meal al fresco. The menu boasts a wide array of options, with mouthwatering highlights such as their iconic Sicilian slices and rich deep-dish pizzas that transport you back in time, as noted by loyal patrons who swear by the nostalgic taste of the homemade sauce.

  • Takeout and Delivery: Whether you're in a rush or wish to savor your pizza at home, Broadway Pizzeria ensures convenience with options for takeout and delivery.
  • Reservations: Perfect for family gatherings or group outings, the restaurant accommodates reservations for a hassle-free dining experience.
  • Kid-Friendly: Kids will love the delightful selection, making it a fantastic spot for family lunches.
  • Good for Groups: With ample seating and a lively atmosphere, it’s an ideal location for group get-togethers.
  • Cash Only: As a classic nod to its roots, Broadway Pizzeria operates on a cash-only basis, ensuring a straightforward dining experience.
  • Signature Dishes: Don't miss out on the highly praised Big Mac Slice or their hearty Philly cheese steak—both fan favorites that showcase their commitment to fresh, quality ingredients.

The charm of Broadway Pizzeria lies not only in its delicious offerings but also in its ability to create a sense of belonging. Just ask longtime customers who recall fond memories of their visits from years past, sharing stories over slices of hot, cheesy goodness.

If you’re seeking a slice of nostalgia wrapped in deliciousness, look no further than Broadway Pizzeria & Restaurant. With its extensive menu, inviting ambiance, and a strong sense of community, this pizzeria is more than just a stop for food—it's an experience. Visit today and discover why Broadway Pizzeria is hailed as the number one spot for pizza in Paterson!

START YOUR REVIEW OF Broadway Pizzeria & Restaurant
J K.
J K.

The people who work here are friendly and the food is good. I have only had their Sicilian slices (visited 3-4 times. I will go back and try a few slices. The place is small, but they do have a few tables for outside dining, so I order pick up.

Will G.
Will G.

It's been a few years since I've been to this pizza grub spot. Traffic can be a bit much if you try accessing it through Main Street - so do yourself a favor and figure out your way around Main Street to get here. There is only street parking. When I got there, my mom needed to use the restroom but it was "out of order". We sat near the front of the restaurant and ordered two knishes - beef hand pies, and my mom got a slice of thin crust pizza that was topped with ham, sausage & pepperoni. She dug it. I had a slice of their Special of the Day - it was a deep dish pizzas which tasted like it had meatballs on it. It was DELICIOUS!! It's gotta be the sauce cause I swear it brought me back 45 years!!! It's been that long. I definitely recommend it. I'm looking forward to coming back.

Betty S.
Betty S.

I love broadway pizza always fresh hot and cheap love that they have dollar uptown's wide variety of pizza the crust is heaven and I can sop up all the grease from all that melted gooey cheese yummm!!!! Hold up I just had a Big Mac Slice and it was so good

Angela L.
Angela L.

Def number one spot in Paterson for pizza. The pizza was made to order with fresh ingredients . There is seating inside it's not that big but decent for a quick stop. I have had a salad from here before as well and it was fresh. They told us it would take 20 min for our 2 pies to be ready but it was ready in 10. Cash only but worth it. The individual slices are worth a quick stop by .

Natasha S.
Natasha S.

I had a slice of pizza and a tuna salad. The salad had a lot of tuna. Huge portion! It tasted good, I couldn't eat the whole pizza so I have enough for lunch tomorrow.

Lashawn P.
Lashawn P.

Well I've been going here for years and at one point I hadn't patronized the biz in years. But let me tell you when I walked in they remembered me replying "Hey where you been, long time no see". My high school friends and I would visit here after school at least twice a week(way back in the day) or sometimes we would simply walk downtown just to have a slice of pizza. Now don't even pay attention to the locals standing in front trying to sell you something; ignore them and go get your slice of pizza or grilled chicken Caesar salad or your hot dog all the way or meatball sub or whatever it is you would like off the menu. The slices are always fresh and hot and don't you dare complain lol. Do I ever complain? Yes but with a smile.... It's always busy during lunch time so be patient but the workers are pretty fast so don't worry; you can get in and out. Cash only$$$$ When I was pregnant, I would always order a salad with provolone cheese nothing special but there was this young man who made it with love. He ended up leaving and I was distraught. The manager said "Don't worry we will make it how you want it, relax". Of course, they made it just how I liked it; who could ignore my pouty face/big belly. Recently, I visited late on Friday (closing) and they gave me a pie at a discounted rate. So if you have jury duty, court appearance, shopping for hair/wigs, unlocking your boos phone, getting discounted dental across street, or simply looking for an authentic slice go to Broadway Pizza!

Tasty C.
Tasty C.

This is as close as you will get to a New York slice! You definitely need to try them, unfortunately they do not deliver. One of the best pizzeria in Paterson. You must try the Broadway Super Sub it is delicious and so big that two people can eat. There is so much meat that it barely fits in the bread but yet holds up well when you dig in.

Chris L.
Chris L.

The best pizzeria in the area. The food/$ ratio is good. I usually order a Philly cheese steak here with onion and mushroom and ketchup. I recommend calling ahead if your not in and out for a slice. Avoid the 1 dollar pizza across the street unless your a bum. Cash only.